Last month, I spoke to a room full of business owners and leaders in the construction and trade space. They run crews, manage foremen, and carry payroll for people who build things for a living. Partway through our conversation, we hit a topic I've talked through with some of the top sales teams in the country, and the reaction was the same as it always is.
Heads nodded, and a few people winced.
The topic was how leaders spend their coaching time, and the mistake almost all of them are making with their best people.
The leadership mistake that costs you your A players
You spend almost all of your time coaching, developing, and investing in your medium and low performers. They're the ones missing targets, making mistakes, and showing up in your meetings, so they get your attention.
Your high performers get left alone.
The reasoning sounds solid. You don't want to micromanage them. You don't want to peer over their shoulder. They're doing great, so you leave them alone and let them thrive.
The problem is that great performers have a drive to get better. That drive is the reason they're great. It's also the reason they want coaching, want feedback, and need to hear from you. When you leave them alone, you're withholding the exact thing that made them great in the first place.
The A student problem
Think back to grade school.
If you were the A student, crushing it all year long, your teacher eventually stopped praising you when you got an A. The A was expected. Then the D student suddenly made a C or a B minus, and everyone wanted to throw a party.
You sat there thinking, "I've been doing better than them all year. Let me go somewhere I'm better appreciated."
In grade school, you couldn't do much about that feeling. At work, your top performer can. They can update a resume, take the recruiter's call, or say yes to the competitor who has been trying to hire them for a year.
Why top performers leave
I call the slow, invisible backward movement that happens when people stop competing forward drift. Drift doesn't announce itself, and it almost never looks like a crisis while it's happening.
With top performers, the drift usually doesn't start in their effort. Their numbers often hold for a while. What drifts first is their belief that your organization is still the place where they'll grow.
When the feedback stops, their scoreboard goes dark, and when the scoreboard goes dark, drift accelerates. They start asking themselves whether anyone notices, whether there's a next level here, and whether someone somewhere else would invest in them more. Eventually they go somewhere they're getting coached, getting feedback, and having people pour into them.
There's a leadership version of Victory Drift hiding inside this. Your team's wins convinced you that your winners didn't need you anymore. The win is what set the trap.
How to retain top performers: two conversations that matter
After I posted a video on this, my friend and fellow speaker Courtney added a playbook in the comments that I think every leader should steal. Her point was simple: if you want to keep your top performers, two things better happen often.
1. The career conversation (every three to four months)
This is a dedicated conversation about the person, not the project. Courtney frames it around three things:
What's working
Where they want to go
What they need from you to help get them there
If there are opportunities to address, address them here too. High performers can handle honest feedback. Most of them are starving for it, because no one has given them any in months.
The career conversation keeps their scoreboard lit. It shows them the next level exists and that you're paying attention to whether they reach it.
2. The stay interview (at least twice a year)
Most companies wait for the exit interview to learn why someone left. A stay interview asks those questions while you can still do something about the answer. Courtney's starting questions:
What do you love about your job?
What would you change?
What would convince you to leave tomorrow if it were offered to you?
That last question is uncomfortable to ask, and that's exactly why it matters. You would much rather hear the answer from them in a coffee shop than read it in a resignation letter.
There are plenty more questions you can add. A few I like:
When was the last time you felt stretched here?
What's one skill you want to get better at this year?
What should I keep doing, and what should I stop doing, as your leader?
And as Courtney pointed out, taking them out for coffee or lunch is never a bad idea either.
How often should you meet with your high performers?
You don't have to meet with them every week. But you should be meeting with them every month, if not more than once a month.
A simple rhythm looks like this:
Monthly: a one-on-one focused on their growth, not just their tasks
Every three to four months: a career conversation
Twice a year: a stay interview
That's not micromanagement. Micromanagement is controlling how someone does their work. This is investing in where their work is taking them.
Your 1-2-3 for this week
You don't need a new program to start. You need 30 minutes and one honest conversation.
Book it. Put 30 minutes on the calendar with your top performer before Friday.
Ask about the next level. Ask them what the next level looks like for them and what's standing in the way.
Name something specific. Tell them one specific thing they did well this month. Skip the "great job" and name the actual thing.
Then put the career conversation and the stay interview on the calendar so this doesn't depend on remembering.
Don't ignore them. Invest in them.
Your best performers are always looking for an edge. They want a way to compete, a way to beat yesterday, and a way to get better. You're wired the same way, which is probably part of why you're leading them.
If you aren't the one handing them that edge, someone else will be.
Want help building a coaching rhythm that keeps your best people competing forward? Learn more about bringing Jake to your next leadership event.